Review Tesla Model Y vs Model X - Brutally HONEST Review

[Tom]

The Tesla Model Y and Model X are both electric SUVs that offer distinct features catering to different preferences and needs. Here's a detailed comparison to help you understand their differences and similarities:

Towing Capacity

Model Y: Capable of towing up to 3,500 pounds.
Model X: Offers a higher towing capacity of up to 5,000 pounds.

Powertrain and Performance

Model Y:
Engine Type: Dual electric motors with all-wheel drive.
Horsepower: Approximately 456 hp.
0-60 mph Acceleration: Around 3.5 seconds.
Model X:
Engine Type: Tri-motor setup in the Plaid version with all-wheel drive.
Horsepower: Up to 1,020 hp.
0-60 mph Acceleration: As quick as 2.5 seconds.



Range and Battery

Model Y:
Battery Size: Approximately 75 kWh.
Range: Up to 326 miles on a single charge.
Model X:
Battery Size: Around 100 kWh.
Range: Up to 360 miles on a single charge.

Dimensions and Capacity

Model Y:
Seating Capacity: Up to 7 passengers with optional third row.
Cargo Space: 68 cubic feet with rear seats folded.
Ground Clearance: 6.6 inches.
Dimensions: Length: 187 inches; Width: 75.6 inches; Height: 63.9 inches.
Model X:
Seating Capacity: Up to 7 passengers.
Cargo Space: 88 cubic feet with rear seats folded.
Ground Clearance: 5.4 inches (adjustable with air suspension).
Dimensions: Length: 198.3 inches; Width: 78.7 inches; Height: 66 inches.

Pricing

Model Y: Starts around $54,990.
Model X: Begins at approximately $99,990.

Maintenance and Insurance Costs

Maintenance: Both models require minimal maintenance due to fewer moving parts. However, tire replacements can be frequent due to the vehicle's weight and torque.
Insurance: Insurance premiums vary based on location, driving history, and coverage but tend to be higher for the Model X due to its higher value.

Common Issues and Recalls

Model X: Has experienced recalls, including issues with roof trim adhesive and tire pressure monitoring systems.
Model Y: Also faced recalls related to tire pressure monitoring systems.


Pros and Cons

Model Y Pros:
More affordable.
Compact size suitable for urban environments.
Model Y Cons:
Lower towing capacity.
Less cargo space.
Model X Pros:
Higher performance and towing capacity.
More luxurious features and spacious interior.
Model X Cons:
Higher price point.
Larger size may not be ideal for all drivers.

Conclusion The choice between the Model Y and Model X depends on your specific needs and budget. The Model Y offers a more affordable entry into Tesla's SUV lineup with commendable performance and range, making it suitable for smaller families or individuals. In contrast, the Model X provides superior performance, towing capacity, and luxury features, catering to those seeking a premium electric SUV experience.

 

[Steve]

This is a solid comparison on paper, but in real life the Model Y and Model X feel like they’re built for very different kinds of owners.
The Model Y makes sense if you want an EV you can actually live with every day. It’s easier to park, easier to justify financially, and honestly, it already feels fast enough for 99% of real-world driving. For most families, the towing and cargo limits are rarely a dealbreaker they just want something efficient, quick, and simple to own.
The Model X, on the other hand, is less about “need” and more about want. The performance is wild, the space is genuinely impressive, and if you tow regularly or carry a lot of people and gear, the extra capability matters. But you pay for that in price, size, insurance, and sometimes practicality. It’s not a casual purchase.
One thing worth adding: numbers don’t tell the full story. The Y feels lighter and more agile in daily use, while the X feels like a tech-heavy, luxury statement. Neither is better they just serve very different lifestyles.

If someone is cross-shopping these two, the real question isn’t specs. It’s: Do you want the smartest EV choice… or the most extreme one?