tesla 1
Member
When comparing the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid and the Tesla Model Y in terms of the lowest cost of ownership over five years, there are several factors to evaluate, including purchase price, fuel/electricity costs, maintenance, insurance, depreciation, range, and practicality. Let’s break down these two vehicles:
1. Purchase Price:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Starting price: $31,500 - $40,000 (varies by trim).
Tesla Model Y:
Starting price: $47,740 - $54,990 (depending on version).
Tesla also has incentives for EV buyers depending on your region (federal and local rebates).
The Tesla Model Y is typically more expensive to purchase upfront, but it might qualify for EV tax credits that lower its effective cost.
2. Fuel/Energy Costs:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
The RAV4 Hybrid consumes around 6-6.5L/100 km (38-42 MPG), depending on driving conditions.
For 15,000 miles (24,000 km) per year and fuel at $3.50 per gallon (or €1.50 per liter), annual fuel costs would be roughly $1,300-1,500.
Tesla Model Y:
The Model Y is fully electric with an efficiency of about 16-19 kWh per 100 km.
For 15,000 miles (24,000 km) per year and electricity at $0.13 per kWh, annual charging costs are about $500-600.
Additionally, if you have access to home solar or cheaper overnight electricity rates, your charging costs could be lower.
Winner: Tesla has lower energy costs, particularly if you have access to low-cost or renewable electricity sources.
3. Maintenance & Reliability:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Hybrids have fewer moving parts than traditional gasoline vehicles but more than fully electric cars. Expect regular servicing, including oil changes, brake servicing, and potential hybrid battery checkups.
Toyota's hybrids are known for reliability, and maintenance costs over 5 years are estimated at around $3,000-4,000.
Tesla Model Y:
Being fully electric, the Model Y has very low maintenance requirements. No oil changes, fewer brake replacements (thanks to regenerative braking), and fewer mechanical parts to service.
Tesla’s estimated maintenance over 5 years is about $1,500-2,000.
However, repairs (especially out of warranty) can be expensive.
Winner: Tesla typically has lower maintenance costs due to the fewer parts and less servicing required.
4. Insurance Costs:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Insurance costs for the RAV4 Hybrid are lower, averaging about $1,200-1,500 per year depending on location and driving record.
Tesla Model Y:
Due to its higher initial price and more expensive repairs, the Model Y typically has higher insurance premiums, averaging about $1,500-2,000 per year.
Winner: Toyota has lower insurance costs overall.
5. Depreciation:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Hybrids generally have good resale value, and the RAV4 Hybrid benefits from Toyota’s strong reputation for reliability. Expect about 45-50% depreciation over five years.
Tesla Model Y:
Tesla’s vehicles tend to hold their value well due to the growing demand for electric vehicles and updates to software over time. Depreciation is around 35-45% over five years, though this can vary with market trends.
Winner: Tesla’s resale value has been strong historically, especially with demand for EVs rising.
6. Range and Charging/Refueling:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Fuel tank: 55 liters (14.5 gallons).
Range: Around 600-650 miles (965-1,050 km) on a full tank.
Refueling is quick and can be done anywhere there’s a gas station.
Tesla Model Y:
Long Range: 330-350 miles (530-563 km) per charge.
Performance: 303-315 miles (488-507 km) per charge.
Charging time depends on the charging method. Superchargers can charge from 10% to 80% in 30-40 minutes. Home charging is slower but convenient if available.
Winner: Toyota has a significantly longer range, but Tesla’s range is competitive, especially for an EV.
7. Size and Practicality:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Cargo space: 37.5 cubic feet (1061 liters) with seats up, 69.8 cubic feet (1977 liters) with seats folded.
The RAV4 is slightly more practical for families with more cargo space and a slightly roomier interior.
Tesla Model Y:
Cargo space: 30.2 cubic feet (855 liters) with seats up, 76 cubic feet (2152 liters) with seats folded (including front trunk).
While Tesla’s Model Y has a slightly smaller cabin, it makes up for it with more overall cargo capacity (front and rear combined). It’s highly practical, especially for road trips and luggage.
Winner: Tesla Model Y, thanks to its versatile cargo area, though the RAV4 offers more traditional SUV space.
Youtube
1. Purchase Price:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Starting price: $31,500 - $40,000 (varies by trim).
Tesla Model Y:
Starting price: $47,740 - $54,990 (depending on version).
Tesla also has incentives for EV buyers depending on your region (federal and local rebates).
The Tesla Model Y is typically more expensive to purchase upfront, but it might qualify for EV tax credits that lower its effective cost.
2. Fuel/Energy Costs:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
The RAV4 Hybrid consumes around 6-6.5L/100 km (38-42 MPG), depending on driving conditions.
For 15,000 miles (24,000 km) per year and fuel at $3.50 per gallon (or €1.50 per liter), annual fuel costs would be roughly $1,300-1,500.
Tesla Model Y:
The Model Y is fully electric with an efficiency of about 16-19 kWh per 100 km.
For 15,000 miles (24,000 km) per year and electricity at $0.13 per kWh, annual charging costs are about $500-600.
Additionally, if you have access to home solar or cheaper overnight electricity rates, your charging costs could be lower.
Winner: Tesla has lower energy costs, particularly if you have access to low-cost or renewable electricity sources.
3. Maintenance & Reliability:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Hybrids have fewer moving parts than traditional gasoline vehicles but more than fully electric cars. Expect regular servicing, including oil changes, brake servicing, and potential hybrid battery checkups.
Toyota's hybrids are known for reliability, and maintenance costs over 5 years are estimated at around $3,000-4,000.
Tesla Model Y:
Being fully electric, the Model Y has very low maintenance requirements. No oil changes, fewer brake replacements (thanks to regenerative braking), and fewer mechanical parts to service.
Tesla’s estimated maintenance over 5 years is about $1,500-2,000.
However, repairs (especially out of warranty) can be expensive.
Winner: Tesla typically has lower maintenance costs due to the fewer parts and less servicing required.
4. Insurance Costs:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Insurance costs for the RAV4 Hybrid are lower, averaging about $1,200-1,500 per year depending on location and driving record.
Tesla Model Y:
Due to its higher initial price and more expensive repairs, the Model Y typically has higher insurance premiums, averaging about $1,500-2,000 per year.
Winner: Toyota has lower insurance costs overall.
5. Depreciation:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Hybrids generally have good resale value, and the RAV4 Hybrid benefits from Toyota’s strong reputation for reliability. Expect about 45-50% depreciation over five years.
Tesla Model Y:
Tesla’s vehicles tend to hold their value well due to the growing demand for electric vehicles and updates to software over time. Depreciation is around 35-45% over five years, though this can vary with market trends.
Winner: Tesla’s resale value has been strong historically, especially with demand for EVs rising.
6. Range and Charging/Refueling:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Fuel tank: 55 liters (14.5 gallons).
Range: Around 600-650 miles (965-1,050 km) on a full tank.
Refueling is quick and can be done anywhere there’s a gas station.
Tesla Model Y:
Long Range: 330-350 miles (530-563 km) per charge.
Performance: 303-315 miles (488-507 km) per charge.
Charging time depends on the charging method. Superchargers can charge from 10% to 80% in 30-40 minutes. Home charging is slower but convenient if available.
Winner: Toyota has a significantly longer range, but Tesla’s range is competitive, especially for an EV.
7. Size and Practicality:
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid:
Cargo space: 37.5 cubic feet (1061 liters) with seats up, 69.8 cubic feet (1977 liters) with seats folded.
The RAV4 is slightly more practical for families with more cargo space and a slightly roomier interior.
Tesla Model Y:
Cargo space: 30.2 cubic feet (855 liters) with seats up, 76 cubic feet (2152 liters) with seats folded (including front trunk).
While Tesla’s Model Y has a slightly smaller cabin, it makes up for it with more overall cargo capacity (front and rear combined). It’s highly practical, especially for road trips and luggage.
Winner: Tesla Model Y, thanks to its versatile cargo area, though the RAV4 offers more traditional SUV space.
Youtube