evlover
Member
The BMW X1 30e and X3 30e are both plug-in hybrid SUVs that offer a blend of luxury, performance, and efficiency. While the X3 is traditionally seen as the larger and more premium model, there are nuances between the two that could make the X1 30e a better choice for some drivers, depending on their priorities. Below, I'll break down the key aspects to consider:
1. Price
BMW X1 30e: Typically starts around $47,000 - $50,000 depending on options.
BMW X3 30e: Typically starts around $55,000 - $60,000 depending on options.
The X1 30e is significantly more affordable, which might make it a better value proposition for those who don't need the extra size or features of the X3.
2. Size and Space
BMW X1 30e:
Length: ~4500 mm
Cargo Capacity: 490 liters (expandable to 1,550 liters with seats down)
Passenger Space: Good for its class, but the rear seats are slightly more cramped compared to the X3.
BMW X3 30e:
Length: ~4717 mm
Cargo Capacity: 450 liters (expandable to 1,500 liters with seats down)
Passenger Space: More spacious, especially in the rear seats.
The X3 offers more interior space, which is beneficial for families or those needing extra room, but the X1's smaller size might be more practical for city driving.
3. Electric Range and Battery
BMW X1 30e:
Battery Capacity: 14.2 kWh
Electric Range: ~52-55 km (32-34 miles) WLTP
BMW X3 30e:
Battery Capacity: 12 kWh
Electric Range: ~45-50 km (28-31 miles) WLTP
The X1 30e has a slightly larger battery and a longer electric range, which can be a significant advantage for daily commutes, reducing the need for gasoline use.
4. Fuel Efficiency and Running Costs
Combined Fuel Economy: Both models offer similar fuel efficiency when the electric range is exhausted, around 2.0-2.5 L/100 km when using both electric and gasoline.
100 km Cost:
X1 30e: Slightly lower due to the better electric range and smaller engine size.
X3 30e: Slightly higher fuel consumption due to its larger size and weight.
5. Performance
BMW X1 30e:
Engine: 1.5-liter turbocharged 3-cylinder + electric motor
Combined Power: 245 hp
0-100 km/h: ~6.9 seconds
BMW X3 30e:
Engine: 2.0-liter turbocharged 4-cylinder + electric motor
Combined Power: 292 hp
0-100 km/h: ~6.1 seconds
The X3 30e offers better performance with a more powerful engine, which is noticeable in acceleration and high-speed driving.
6. Driving Experience
Handling: The X1 is more nimble due to its smaller size, making it easier to maneuver in tight spaces. The X3, while still agile, feels more planted and composed, especially at higher speeds.
Ride Comfort: The X3 provides a more comfortable ride, with better absorption of road imperfections, while the X1 can feel a bit firmer, particularly on rough roads.
7. Cold and Hot Weather Efficiency
Cold Weather:
Both models will see a reduction in electric range in cold weather, typically around 20-30%. The X1, with its larger battery, may still offer a slightly better range in these conditions.
Hot Weather:
Battery performance can decrease slightly, but both models have efficient climate control systems that manage heat without significantly affecting range.
8. Technology and Features
BMW X1 30e: Offers a good range of technology, but slightly less advanced compared to the X3. You get a slightly smaller infotainment screen, fewer premium materials, and fewer options for advanced driver assistance systems.
BMW X3 30e: Comes with a more advanced infotainment system, better materials, and more options for customization and advanced technology, like adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and more.
9. Verdict: Which is the Best?
Best for Value: BMW X1 30e – If you are looking for a more affordable option with excellent efficiency, a decent range, and a more compact size, the X1 30e is a fantastic choice.
Best for Space and Comfort: BMW X3 30e – If you need more space, better performance, and are willing to pay extra for a more premium feel and advanced technology, the X3 30e is the better option.
Overall, if "bigger is not always better" resonates with you, the BMW X1 30e might be the better choice. It offers a great balance of performance, efficiency, and practicality, especially for urban environments or those who prioritize cost savings. The X3 30e, on the other hand, offers more space, luxury, and power, making it ideal for those who need or prefer a larger vehicle.
Youtube
1. Price
BMW X1 30e: Typically starts around $47,000 - $50,000 depending on options.
BMW X3 30e: Typically starts around $55,000 - $60,000 depending on options.
The X1 30e is significantly more affordable, which might make it a better value proposition for those who don't need the extra size or features of the X3.
2. Size and Space
BMW X1 30e:
Length: ~4500 mm
Cargo Capacity: 490 liters (expandable to 1,550 liters with seats down)
Passenger Space: Good for its class, but the rear seats are slightly more cramped compared to the X3.
BMW X3 30e:
Length: ~4717 mm
Cargo Capacity: 450 liters (expandable to 1,500 liters with seats down)
Passenger Space: More spacious, especially in the rear seats.
The X3 offers more interior space, which is beneficial for families or those needing extra room, but the X1's smaller size might be more practical for city driving.
3. Electric Range and Battery
BMW X1 30e:
Battery Capacity: 14.2 kWh
Electric Range: ~52-55 km (32-34 miles) WLTP
BMW X3 30e:
Battery Capacity: 12 kWh
Electric Range: ~45-50 km (28-31 miles) WLTP
The X1 30e has a slightly larger battery and a longer electric range, which can be a significant advantage for daily commutes, reducing the need for gasoline use.
4. Fuel Efficiency and Running Costs
Combined Fuel Economy: Both models offer similar fuel efficiency when the electric range is exhausted, around 2.0-2.5 L/100 km when using both electric and gasoline.
100 km Cost:
X1 30e: Slightly lower due to the better electric range and smaller engine size.
X3 30e: Slightly higher fuel consumption due to its larger size and weight.
5. Performance
BMW X1 30e:
Engine: 1.5-liter turbocharged 3-cylinder + electric motor
Combined Power: 245 hp
0-100 km/h: ~6.9 seconds
BMW X3 30e:
Engine: 2.0-liter turbocharged 4-cylinder + electric motor
Combined Power: 292 hp
0-100 km/h: ~6.1 seconds
The X3 30e offers better performance with a more powerful engine, which is noticeable in acceleration and high-speed driving.
6. Driving Experience
Handling: The X1 is more nimble due to its smaller size, making it easier to maneuver in tight spaces. The X3, while still agile, feels more planted and composed, especially at higher speeds.
Ride Comfort: The X3 provides a more comfortable ride, with better absorption of road imperfections, while the X1 can feel a bit firmer, particularly on rough roads.
7. Cold and Hot Weather Efficiency
Cold Weather:
Both models will see a reduction in electric range in cold weather, typically around 20-30%. The X1, with its larger battery, may still offer a slightly better range in these conditions.
Hot Weather:
Battery performance can decrease slightly, but both models have efficient climate control systems that manage heat without significantly affecting range.
8. Technology and Features
BMW X1 30e: Offers a good range of technology, but slightly less advanced compared to the X3. You get a slightly smaller infotainment screen, fewer premium materials, and fewer options for advanced driver assistance systems.
BMW X3 30e: Comes with a more advanced infotainment system, better materials, and more options for customization and advanced technology, like adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and more.
9. Verdict: Which is the Best?
Best for Value: BMW X1 30e – If you are looking for a more affordable option with excellent efficiency, a decent range, and a more compact size, the X1 30e is a fantastic choice.
Best for Space and Comfort: BMW X3 30e – If you need more space, better performance, and are willing to pay extra for a more premium feel and advanced technology, the X3 30e is the better option.
Overall, if "bigger is not always better" resonates with you, the BMW X1 30e might be the better choice. It offers a great balance of performance, efficiency, and practicality, especially for urban environments or those who prioritize cost savings. The X3 30e, on the other hand, offers more space, luxury, and power, making it ideal for those who need or prefer a larger vehicle.
Youtube